Shopping for a diamond, whether for your dream diamond engagement ring or a piece of simulated diamond jewelry, can be intimidating with the many factors that go into the selection process. An easy key to help you determine the best diamond purchase is using the 4Cs of diamond grading. The 4Cs encompass the cut, color, clarity and carat weight of the stone. Understanding how the diamond grading affects the quality will ensure you select the best stone that is also within your budget.
Generally speaking, the better a stone is graded in each of these categories, the more rare and valuable it is. An internally flawless diamond would be at the top of any diamond clarity chart, however, these stones are incredibly rare and expensive. The diamond cut is considered the most important element, as it has the greatest impact on a diamond’s ability to shine and sparkle. Even the highest diamond quality will appear dull and lifeless if it is cut poorly. Next is the diamond color scale, with the rarest, flawless diamonds having absolutely no color or visible hues present. A diamond’s carat size is a measurement of its carat weight and corresponding size. Finally, clarity is evaluated to identify any imperfections within the stone.
Together, these four factors influence both the quality and value of a diamond - both natural mined diamonds and simulated lab grown diamonds. The impact of each will determine the price of a specific stone, but trade-offs can be made in order to stay within your budget and still find a beautiful diamond. As one of the four main factors, diamond clarity is key to understand so you will have the expertise needed to find your perfect diamond or diamond alternative.
What is Diamond Clarity?
Simply put, diamond clarity grading is the assessment of any imperfections or noticeable inclusions on the surface or within a stone. A greater understanding of clarity can be found by answering the question, how are diamonds made?
Natural diamonds are formed of carbon deep within the earth that is subjected to tremendous heat and pressure, and through this process, some defects may develop. These defects include surface irregularities - known as blemishes - and internal flaws - known as inclusions. Since most stones have microscopic blemishes and inclusions, undetectable to the naked eye, diamond clarity is the least important factor when purchasing a diamond. Therefore, clarity is truly the assessment of the relative absence of these defects.
Blemishes most commonly include scratches and nicks on a diamond’s surface. Inclusions, on the other hand, are slightly more complex. Though they are generally on the inside of a stone, in some cases they might break through the surface. Some inclusions are actually tiny diamonds or other mineral crystals that become trapped inside a diamond when it forms. Depending on their location, these inclusions may linger in the stone after it has been cut and polished, thereby affecting its overall appearance. What makes a diamond sparkle can really be contingent upon how multiple different factors play together.
The Diamond Clarity Scale
The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) developed the now widely accepted standard for determining diamond clarity grade. The clarity scale consists of eleven unique clarity grades divided into six categories. Evaluating a diamond’s clarity requires a trained gemologist to determine the number, size, relief, nature, and position of any blemishes or inclusions and conclude how these affect the overall appearance of the individual stone. Again, no diamond is perfectly free from any imperfections, but many flaws are too small to be seen by anyone other than a trained diamond expert. Expert and accurate assessment of clarity are extremely important, since the closer a diamond comes to achieving perfection, the higher its value. Below are the six categories of the GIA diamond clarity chart.
- Flawless (FL). To achieve a diamond clarity grade of FL, a skilled grader must not see any visible inclusions in or blemishes on the diamond even under 10x magnification. It is nearly impossible to find a diamond that is 100% free of inclusions, so a flawless diamond is incredibly rare. In fact, it is estimated that less than 1% of all diamonds have FL clarity.
- Internally Flawless (IF). IF diamonds will have no visible inclusions when viewed under 10x magnification by a skilled grader, though some blemishes may be seen. IF diamonds are not as rare as FL grade diamonds but are still incredibly uncommon.
- Very, Very Slightly Included (VVS). Consisting of two grades, VVS1 and VVS2, these diamonds have minute inclusions that are generally very difficult for even a trained diamond expert to see under 10x magnification. VVS2 diamonds have slightly more inclusions than VVS1 diamonds, though either grade is still considered to be an excellent quality diamond.
- Very Slightly Included (VS). Again made up of two grades, VS1 and VS2 clarity, VS diamonds have minor inclusions that can be either difficult or relatively easy for a skilled grader to identify under 10x magnification. Similar to the previous category, a VS1 grade diamond has better clarity than a VS2 but both are less expensive than preceding grades. VS diamonds make up a majority of the diamonds typically purchased.
- Slightly Included (SI). Comprised of two additional grades, SI1 and SI2, these diamonds have noticeable inclusions that are easily visible to a skilled grader using 10x magnification. In the case of SI1 diamond clarity, inclusions are sometimes detectable to an experienced grader without magnification, while SI2 grade diamonds are usually noticeable without the visual assistance of magnification.
- Included (I). The final three grades are I1, I2 and I3 clarity, composing the sixth and final category of grading. These diamonds have obvious inclusions that may be detected by a trained grader without the use of magnification. In some cases, these inclusions affect the transparency and brilliance of the diamond.
Determining Diamond Clarity Grade
As mentioned previously, there are a number of elements that a trained and skilled gemologist considers in order to determine the clarity grade of a diamond. These factors mostly refer to diamond inclusions and involve:
- Number. Most obviously, a higher quantity of present flaws will result in a lower clarity grade. This is examined as a total number of both inclusions and blemishes.
- Size. Larger inclusions or blemishes will also have a greater impact on a diamond’s clarity than more minute ones. This is due to the fact that a bigger flaw is likely more noticeable without magnification or skilled training.
- Relief. This refers to the visibility of an inclusion in contrast to the diamond itself. A higher relief will appear darker in color against the rest of the stone, resulting in a lower grade.
- Nature. This factor regards the type of inclusion that is present in relation to the depth or other characteristics of the diamond itself. Any flaw situated on the diamond’s surface that has not penetrated the interior is referred to as a blemish, not an inclusion. While blemishes are not desirable themselves, inclusions are the more problematic flaw in clarity grading.
- Position. Where the inclusion is located on a diamond is critical in determining its clarity. An inclusion that is close to the center of the stone’s table, or the flat top surface, will have a stronger negative impact on the stone’s clarity than an inclusion closer to the girdle, the widest rim of the stone. This is because an inclusion near the center of the table will be more visible. Similarly, inclusions found near the pavilions of the diamond, the facets which slope down, can reflect. The facets act as mirrors, which can make imperfections in this location difficult to see.
All of these factors are considered in order to determine the clarity grade of a diamond. However, certain flaws can be obscured or emphasized by the shape, proportions, and facet arrangement of the diamond. So, a poor clarity rating is not the end-all-be-all for every diamond.
Diamond Alternatives on the Clarity Scale
There is a multitude of different diamond options aside from natural, mined diamonds in today’s market, giving consumers more alternatives to consider than ever before. Having an understanding of the clarity diamond grading of lab grown diamonds and diamond alternatives can be helpful in assessing various diamond options and answering the question, are lab diamonds real?
Lab grown diamonds are composed of carbon, similar to a natural diamond, and therefore are subject to the same types of flaws and inclusions. These are measured on the same GIA diamond clarity scale. Another option, Moissanite, is not consistently graded on its clarity characteristic, so will be a bit harder to measure in terms of price and quality.
Nexus Diamond™ alternatives are lab created diamond alternatives that are crafted specifically to have IF rated clarity. The patented chemical formula used to create the diamond alternative imitates the look, weight and feel of a traditionally mined diamond, but can be manipulated to create flawless simulant stones that are of the highest grading on every scale. With Nexus Diamond alternatives, you can ensure a perfect stone, but at a much more affordable price and with an ethical & environmentally friendly guarantee.
What is the Best Diamond Clarity?
When considering the clarity characteristic, it’s important to remember that all natural diamonds contain imperfections. They are created under extreme pressure and mined from the earth, which is a far from perfect process. If you are considering a natural diamond purchase, do not feel like you should only be looking at FL or IF diamonds. In fact, when it comes to natural diamonds, the best value is found in a stone that has inclusions that cannot be seen with the naked eye or through the top of the stone without magnification, more commonly known as an eye-clean diamond. These include stones with clarity diamond grading as low as VS or even SI and come at a much more affordable price than diamonds with higher grades.
It is also important to understand that a diamond’s shape and size will impact a diamond’s clarity. Be sure to do a carat size comparison because as a diamond’s size increases, so too do the size of its facets that can act as windows to the interior of the stone. If facets are bigger, this has the potential to make inclusions easier to see. Similarly, diamond shapes that have larger facets, such as emerald or Asscher, emphasize the transparency of a diamond. This allows you to see deeper into the interior, which can make inclusions more visible. Alternatively, round, princess, oval, marquise and pear shapes have intricate facet patterns that reflect light from many angles which, in turn, can naturally hide inclusions.
A notable alternative to natural diamonds, especially when it comes to clarity, is a diamond alternative. There is a wealth of options available to you, from lab grown to Nexus Diamond alternatives. While most of these will be generally more affordable than natural diamonds, where they can really stand out is on the diamond clarity scale. Empowered with the knowledge of the clarity scale and how it affects diamond quality, you are poised to find the diamond of your dreams, for any of your jewelry needs!
*Diamond Nexus strives to provide valuable information, while being clear and honest about our products. The Nexus Diamond™ alternative is a patented lab grown stone that, among all simulants, most closely imitates the look, weight and wear of a mined diamond, with two exceptions - it is absolutely perfect in every way, and it costs significantly less. Price points and environmental facts expressed in this blog were taken from popular online retailers and may vary. Learn more about the environmental impact of mining by visiting our blog.